4 Features Retirement Plans Should Have

February 9, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (2)

The U.S. retirement system is far from perfect. However, there are a few simple ways that retirement accounts could be greatly improved. Here are four fixes that would give all of us a better chance at a comfortable retirement.

[See 10 Winter Wonderlands for Retirement.]

Reduce the options. Investors have an intimidating amount of retirement account choices, each with different rules. While traditional 401(k)s and IRAs are the most common, there are also Roth IRAs, Rollover IRAs, SEP IRAs, Individual 401(k)s, and Simple 401(k)s. Who can actually keep the facts straight? Every time I call customer support about the different options available, everyone seems to give me conflicting advice about the accounts. It would helpful if the government could simplify all the retirement account choices. When the options are simple and everything is clear-cut, the only way companies can gain our business is to offer better terms that actually matter to us.

Low cost choices. Contributing to a traditional IRA is sometimes cited as a better strategy than putting money in a 401(k) because you have access to just about any type of investment and can shop around for the lowest fees. Why can't 401(k)s have the same choices or be required to offer affordable options such as low cost index funds? When you have access to fee information, it’s easier to pick cost-effective investments.

[See The 9 S’s of Retirement Success.]

Independent investment education. In our do-it-yourself retirement system, it is essential that everyone be educated about investing their own money. But many people continue to make very basic investment mistakes. Many employers offer 401(k) education seminars, but these courses are often short and instructed by the company administering your 401(k). We need to learn the investment basics from someone not trying to sell us something.

[See 6 Important People for Your Retirement.]

Don’t allow early withdrawals. The 10 percent early withdrawal penalty has not deterred all investors from raiding their retirement accounts before retirement. There are also a variety of ways to avoid the penalty altogether. The ability to take early withdraws and loans from retirement accounts allows many people to get themselves into a bad position come retirement time. The money in retirement accounts should be used only to finance retirement.

David Ning runs MoneyNing, a personal finance site aimed at helping others change their habits for a better financial future. He suggests that everyone to sign up for an online savings account to get more out of our hard earned money.

Tags:
retirement

Reader Comments Read all comments (2)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

There are lots of cheap ways for investors to lose money. Cheaper isn't always better. I agree that SEP IRAS and ROTH IRAs etc are superfluousness and could be simplified - along with the rest of the US tax code. We could start by eliminating all income phase-outs and make contribution limits identical across all platforms.

Restricting access to people's money (via larger penalties in this case) is never a good idea. (unless you are the one collecting the penalties!)

I do think that it would be nice if investors in 401k's had the ability to have a guaranteed income listed - maybe a guaranteed annuitization option - similar to VAs but maybe with the PBGC backing the insurance company guarantees. If participants could see the effects additions, growth, stopping contributions, and early withdraws have on their ultimate retirement income they might think twice before embarking on a foolhardy endeavor.

As it stands right now investors are entitled to 13 years of free public education yet far too many people walk away from this gift. More 'free' education isn't better - we just need a better system than the one we have. Frankly - even well educated investors make egregious mistakes - such as the fallacy that there can be substantially better returns on an asset without the corresponding increase in risk. This was evident with the derivative mortgage backed securities preceding the last crisis.. They were originated, insured, and bought by pros who thought they could do an end-run around risk... It didn't really work out that way at all. It never does. Even with real estate we saw that. Who never heard some nimrod proclaim "You can't lose money with land!"?

The fundamentals of investing are simple - but everyone thinks they can beat the averages, reinvent the wheel, and are entitled to be exempt from the rules. The rules being : high risk does not always mean high return but high return always means high risk ; diversification isn't perfect but it works well at reducing risk over time; it isn't a sprint it is a marathon; it is better to never run out of money than it is to never lose any.

Investment advisers are like car mechanics - not all are good, but if you find a good one latch on; Investments are like cars - they come in many sizes, shapes and intended purposes and you don't need to know how to build one in order to drive one.

Ultimately I think Americans need more education (sometime in the 13 years they currently get) on risk. Specifically how to know which risks to take, which to avoid and which to transfer. Many people take foolish risks, including (ironically) the avoidance of all perceived risk. Many more think they can transfer ALL risk to a 3rd party such as the government or their insurance company... for free. This foolish thinking will be the death of us. Risk is a part of life which cannot be denied, avoided, or ignored. In fact it should be embraced for without it life would be quite dull.

Eric of FL 8:00AM February 12, 2011

By the time someone gets to needing to cash out retirement, the penalty doesn't matter. People are desperate.

The problem comes way before that. Increasing the penalty is just kicking someone when they're down. When everyone from govt leaders to friends next door try to make us "spend," there is no way this problem will be corrected.

Chris Grande

Walnut Hill Advisors, LLC

Chris Grande of MA 9:30PM February 10, 2011

On Retirement

Retirement planning ideas and advice from top personal finance and lifestyle bloggers, including Money Ning, Live and Invest Overseas, Dan Solin, Good Financial Cents, Retire by 40, Retirement–Only the Beginning, Free Money Finance, Money Crashers, The Dough Roller, and Sightings at 60.

advertisement

Our retirement readiness calculator will provide a rough idea of how long your retirement savings and income will last.


Latest Video

advertisement