Best Buy's Policy Snares Customer With New TV

August 27, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (15)

Earlier this week, I heard from Jennifer, a Best Buy customer who bought a new, 40-inch, flat-screen television for $1,100 at a store in Wheaton, Md. When she brought it home in its sealed box, she found that the entire screen had been smashed. So, as irritating as that would be, you would think that at least the store would exchange it for an undamaged one, right?

Wrong. When Jennifer took the television back to the store, customer service representatives told her the store could not replace it, because the company can't be responsible for what happens after products leave the store. Eventually, the store offered to pay for half of the repairs on the damaged television—which still leaves her out $500 and without the brand-new set she paid for.

I asked Best Buy about this policy. Senior executive resolution specialist Jill Nezworski says that if customers transport a television themselves, then Best Buy can't verify what happens to it once it leaves the store. That's why Best Buy doesn't allow returns or exchanges on damaged units that were transported by customers. But if Best Buy delivers the television, then the company guarantees the condition of the product until it's in the customer's home.

The lesson: Open the box and check to make sure nothing is damaged before leaving the store. Or have the store deliver pricey products so the company is responsible for any damage you find upon opening the box.

Tags:
Best Buy,
shopping,
television

Reader Comments Read all comments (15)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I bought a TV from Best Buy appx. 110 pm Saturday 26 Feb and went home when I did my stuff I had to do I return home happy to open my TV box my wife notice it has a crack I took it back and the salesperson says one second she gets the manager and he says I dropped it and he is not taking it back I said no I did not you show me that it looks dropped no dings or cracks or anything then he says well you dropped it face first then I say its in possible the plastic is in tact and the screen has only two lines.

I then told him your employee help me put it in my car and said Im good to go so he then calls the employee and the employee says yea I helped him the TV box was fine then the manager says well you broke it putting it in your car I saw you when you was doing it I ask him REALLY what color is my car he then said I dont remember but Im not taking it. I said please help me here I am a Veteran and why would even question my integrity I would never damage this TV I need help!

He then said call coporate but I'm done talking to you So I left call coporate they call the manager the guy on the phone tells me sorry but the manager says it is your fault the I speak to the people that makes the TV and says that he cant help.

So then I call consumer relation they say that the mangaer said no that I have to deal with the store I said why am I going through this this is not right. She said the thing is how do Best buy know you didnt damage it and I said okay how do I know best buy didnt drop it.

I explain to her there is no reason to do this I never did anything to the TV the manager had to her that the TV looked like I was trying to put the screws on the back to mount it I told her negative I have the TV and you can send someone here to check it its still intact. This is not fair So if I buy a TV and didnt open the box then I'm done. Best Buy never told me hey open the box here check it because we are not taking it back or anything like that this is wrong

brokentv of CT 1:32PM February 28, 2011

My wife just bought a 40 in flat screen Samsung-- brought it home- took it out of the box-- and it had a crack at the bottom, above the Samsung label with spider veins that ran up the screen. Of course it did not work. She called best buy, and they baid to bring it in. When she brought it in-they REFUSED TO TAKE IT BACK OR CREDIT OUR ACCOUNT. They said that the box was not damaged and we needed to contact Samsung. After several calls with rude inept managers at the best buy in Niles Illinois-they still refused to take this back- I have called customer service and have heard nothing from thme. I finally called Visa and they are issuing a full credit. I will continue to let the Northshore area of Chicago know of this and to not buy from best buy as they will not provide any hint of customer service when it comes to returning a damaged TV. ALso there are many comments online describing the same rude, inept behavior. This must be a new tacitic for them to rid themselves of damaged merchadise--that probably got damaged in house. I wonder if they train their staff to react this way as the story seems to be the same across the board. We will only go to ABT from now on.

peteGOSCHY of IL 9:24PM April 27, 2010

I personaly dealt with a situation about a customer who's screen was purchased about an hour ago and was found damaged once opening the box. Box was intact but screen was smashed, I was asked, and I sugested that if we take it back the Manufacter would reinburse us the full price of the product and if we dont we loose the customer and 10 of his friends/family members.

That department supervisor then spoke to someone else and both Supervisor and Associate blamed customer for damaging the Screen.

I personaly felt SOOO bad that I sent my resume the following day Wends, was called Thurs, and began working else where Sun. And must say "I am SOO happy now that I dont need to feel responsible for other peoples bad decisions"

Jose Miguel Cruz of NY 1:13PM March 03, 2009

Alpha Consumer

Kimberly Palmer, senior editor for U.S. News & World Report, writes about making smarter financial decisions. She’s the author of Generation Earn: The Young Professional's Guide to Spending, Investing, and Giving Back.

advertisement

Latest Video

advertisement