Fraud Protection: Debit Versus Credit Cards

Reader Comments
Back to blog

DO NOT USE MOMENTUM DEBIT CARDS. THROUGH THE CHECK CASHING STORES, ALL OF THESE CARDS ARE SUBJECT TO FRAUD. YOU HAVE NO RECOURSE AT ALL TO EVEN REPORT FRAUD ON THIS CARD AS NO ONE WILL GIVE YOU THE FRAUD DEPARTEMENT NUMBER AS THEY SAID IT IS OUTGOING NUMBER ONLY. U LEAVE MESSAGE AND NO ONE CALLS. ITS ALL FRAUD FROM THE BANCCORP BANK TO DOLLAR FINANCIAL TO MOMENTUM PREPAID DEBIT ETC. THEY NEED TO BE PROSECUTED.

ANONOMOUSE of FL 3:48AM April 26, 2013

Being a regular online shopper, I always use credit card. But just to be very sure about my security I did some research about some powerful tools to prevent credit card fraud successfully. And then, I came across with one of the most effective and powerful security solution offered by TeleSign whose phone based authentication and verification ensure the complete safety of your personal details to get hacked.
TO read more about their services visit http://www.telesign.com/use-cases/protect-account-access/

Laura Deitch of CA 6:27AM December 14, 2011

I cannot speak on how it works for debit cards, but I work for a major bank in credit card services and I can only assure you that, signature or no, if fraud is determined to have been committed on a cardholder's account, the amount is "charged back" from the merchant. The merchant loses the funds and the cardholder recovers them, regardless of whether or not the merchant has a signed sales slip. In cases of confirmed fraud, the banks are authorized to reverse the charges against the merchants, since generally the actual fraudster is long gone.

Jason of NC 2:32PM June 14, 2011

basejumper1000
Your wrong. If the merchant provides a receipt with a signature ( no matter what it looks like) the financial institution is then responsible for refunding the money. The merchant does not have any responsibily then.

NOBODYS BUSINESS of PA 4:01PM November 22, 2010

John from NJ, your assumption is logical but not the case. When the customer reports a transaction as fraudulent, if the signature of the customer at time of purchase doesn't match the lawful owner of the card then the CC company has the ability to take the funds back from the retailer in question. Thus, the retailer has basically given the product away for free.

Les ecker of CA 5:09PM April 21, 2010

When a mastercard debit/credit is fraudulent and presented at a point-of-sale with a forged signature, why isn't the merchant responsible for not obtaining an ID to verify the signature? It appears that the issuing bank has to take the loss for an invalid signature and the merchant only has to present a copy of the sale agreement with any type of signature.

John Carsone of NJ 12:06PM March 22, 2010

Capital One had a massive card data theft last week. They are covering it up, but anyone with a card knows that their account is being shut down and new cards are being issued. I guess that it is more important to save face than to prevent fraud, protect customers, and punish criminals.

Adam Gibson of MI 8:53AM August 27, 2009

Use a credit card, Amex for instance who are strong in this category. I too pull out that debit card even when I know better. "It'll never happen to me!" Better to be safe, and read your fine print. Great article, thanks!
John
BDCreditCards

John of GA 5:13PM August 20, 2009

To state that the level of protection offered by debit cards and credit cards is identical, as mandated by law and common practice, obscures the issue of what a consumer is actually entitled to. As I understand it, the laws and implementing regulations on consumer rights regarding debit and credit cards are quite different. In debit, I believe there's a three-tier system. You get best protection if you report the problem within 48 hours. Another level of protection if you report within 60 days. If you don't report the problem by then, you are liable for the whole loss. I think it's true that in practice the issuers and networks try to close the gap in protection. But if you're trying to get your money back, you may appreciate the distinction between what they "give" you and what you're entitled to by law.

Clint Swift of TX 9:52AM August 20, 2009

Banks, debit/credit card issuers and other FIs must consider putting the control into the hands of the individuals, in the form of mobile SMS alerts. Clickatell provides SMS credit/debit card/account transaction notifications to enable anytime, anywhere alerts between financial service providers and their customers, giving power to consumers to scrutinize transactions as they happen; not waiting for the fraud to get out of control.

Kelly Brieger of CA 5:43PM August 19, 2009