• Comment (28)

Why Quitting a Job Can Make Financial Sense

September 21, 2011 RSS Feed Print

This week, I wrote about when it makes financial sense to quit your job, which might sound like a ridiculous question. In this economy, does it ever make sense to leave a job? Well, yes, it turns out, and sometimes doing so can even be a smart financial move.

[In Pictures: 10 Ways to Start Earning Extra Money Now]

As I was researching this story, my first big surprise was just how common it is to leave jobs voluntarily. Even now, in the midst of a sluggish economy, between 1.5 and 2 million people quit their jobs each month. That number has come down, though, and a useful paper from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that the number of people quitting jobs appears to vary inversely with the economy. That makes sense: When people feel less secure, they hold onto the jobs they have. Still, the fact that the number of people quitting is still so high shows just how flexible the job market is. People—many people—leave jobs every day.

As for why people leave their jobs, the reasons are as varied as the types of jobs that exist. People leave to care for their children (or their parents), because they’re miserable, or just because they want to try something new. One of the people I interviewed for the article, Chrisanne Sternal, explained that she simply felt she could not juggle the demands of raising her 18-month-old son as well as her forty-hour a week job as a marketing consultant. Her son has some special needs which require extra doctors’ appointments. Every day, she says, she feels like she’s letting somebody down.

Other people’s stories were driven by the dream of replacing their job with something big. Katherine Kallinis and Sophie LaMontagne, the founders of Georgetown Cupcake, who were recently profiled on Alpha Consumer, explained that they left their jobs in fashion and venture capital, respectively, because they had always wanted to launch their own bakery. They knew it was a risk, but they decided they were willing to take it—and now, of course, that risk has more than paid off.

Some of the career coaches and experts I interviewed for the story made the point that if a person is completely miserable in their job, then the money concerns can be secondary. If your job is making you depressed, for example, it can make it harder to move forward and look for new opportunities.

What do you think: Can it be financially responsible to quit your job, even in a down economy? What, if anything, would motivate you to quit?

Twitter: @alphaconsumer

Tags:
personal finance

Reader Comments Read all comments (28)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

note to Ellen: you are not wrong to look for a new job. I just gave my two week notice at a job that sounds very similar to what you describe. I knew that if I stayed there, even after being there for five years, it would destroy me and my paece of mind. There have been so many manager and personnel changes here that it is no longer fun to work here. I hated going in to work each day and all the inspiration and enjoyment has gone out of my work because of the people I work with and the general attitude of the employer. I have left not having another job lined up but I have faith that I will find something else. I believe that it is important to get out of a job that makes you depressed, otherwise you cannot present a positive image at a new job opportunity or even get the energy to pursue one. I know I have to be very careful financially until I get another job, but I am willing to take that risk. I even know where the local soup kitchens are if I really need little help. I am not afraid to use those resources for a little while.

Suzie of MA 9:07AM September 27, 2011

This article does make logical sense...quit your job if you're miserable, and it's not worth getting sick from. However, that it makes financial sense to quit is nonsense if you really need the second income. And yes, 'needing' to work is not always what these career women who have a husband making 200K need to do. They only work themselves just to have 2 Mercedes!! Sad for the kids...kids would rather drive in a Ford and have mom around more!! However, in many women's cases, if their husband's make 40K and they have a family of 3, 4, 5 or more, you better believe in almost all parts of the country 40K is poverty level if you have a mortgage and basic bills!! You DO need to work, sadly, in those cases.

Lisa of IL 7:23AM September 27, 2011

I left my job to stay a home with my kids. I worked second shift with one in school. I hardly saw him except in the mornings when I was putting him on the school bus. By the time I got home at night they were asleep. I felt like I was neglecting my kids and with the summer comming up, daycare was gonna be killler! So my husband and I decided it would be good for me to stay at home, less expensive anyway. What I didn't figure in was my sanity lost over the summer with all three at home and now that school is back and two are in school now I have yet to find a job!

Robin of TX 9:55PM September 26, 2011

Alpha Consumer

Kimberly Palmer, senior editor for U.S. News & World Report, writes about making smarter financial decisions. She’s the author of Generation Earn: The Young Professional's Guide to Spending, Investing, and Giving Back.

advertisement

Latest Video

advertisement