5 Reasons to Skip Black Friday Sales

November 22, 2011 RSS Feed Print

This year’s Black Friday deals are impressive: The coupon site Brad’s Deals reports that at Best Buy, you can get a 42-inch LCD television for $200, a Blu-ray player for $40, and a Lenovo laptop for $180. But do those discounts really justify standing in line, in the cold, for hours on Thanksgiving evening, when you could be home watching a movie instead? (This year, many stores plan to open at midnight or earlier on Thanksgiving instead of in the early morning hours on Friday.)

[In Pictures: 10 Ways to Start Earning Extra Money Now]

Telling shoppers to avoid sales might sound hypocritical coming from someone who has reported on the best deals and discounts out there. But there are some very good reasons why you should turn and walk the other way rather than let yourself be sucked into holiday sale mania. Here are five of them:

Many discounts will continue long after Black Friday is over. While certain so-called “doorbusters” are available for a limited time only (and in limited quantities), many deals will continue throughout the holiday season. (And, in fact, some, such as free shipping at online stores, are often available throughout the year.)

The best deals are only available to a few people. Those doorbusters aren’t available in endless supply, which is why people line up so early in the hopes of being among the lucky few to snag one. While stores vary in how many doorbusters they keep in stock, Best Buy’s ad specifies that stores will sell a minimum of 10 Lenovos for $180, for example. Circulars featuring Black Friday ads often contain information on the number of doorbusters, which helps shoppers gauge how competitive the day will be.

When you do score a discount, it often just leads to more spending. If you've ever impulsively bought a muffin to go with your coffee, or surprised yourself by buying a whole new outfit when you meant to get only a shirt, then you will understand why research shows that shopping leads to more shopping.

Shopping can be broken into two phases, researchers say. In the first stage, people question whether they want to make a purchase. When they decide that the pros outweigh the cons, the "buying phase" takes over. "Once that happens, a roller coaster of shopping can begin," says Uzma Khan, assistant professor of marketing at the Stanford Graduate School of Business and one of the study's authors. The researchers call the phenomenon "shopping momentum."

That means shopping sales can have the unintended consequence of leading to even more purchases, including ones that aren’t on sale. Plus, many of the items that aren’t doorbusters aren’t even good deals, which is one reason shoppers should bring their smartphones and use them to compare prices on products before making purchases. (Certain apps, such as Pricegrabber’s, make it easy to scan barcodes and see if a better deal is available elsewhere.)

[In Pictures: 10 Ways to Save on Food Costs]

Sales that get you to buy something you wouldn’t have purchased otherwise are not good deals. It’s just like the old joke: A woman brags to her husband about how much money she saved on a pair of shoes, and then he points out that she didn’t save any money, she spent it, because she really doesn’t need the shoes. The bottom line: Only take advantage of discounts when they’re on items you would be purchasing anyway, even without the deal.

Frenzied buying almost never leads to smart shopping. One-day sales, midnight madness, and other sales techniques that spur quick decision-making tend to be disorienting and lead to over spending, says Kit Yarrow, consumer psychologist and author of coauthor of Gen BuY: How Tweens, Teens, and Twenty-Somethings Are Revolutionizing Retail. "They're training [consumers] to purchase even though they may not be ready," she says. "If people are buying for fear or anxiety that it won't be available, then they're less likely to make good purchasing decisions."

Here are some alternative ways to spend your Black Friday: Giving back or volunteering, eating turkey leftovers, and getting an early start on Christmas movies. Most of the discounts will still be there when you’re ready to hit the stores.

Twitter: @alphaconsumer

Tags:
personal finance

Reader Comments Read all comments (8)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

yes , black friday is a big hype that bait people in . Stores know you will buy more than what you went after in the first place. It's like Henny Penny wih the sky is falling mentality. If you need it bad enough, it will be there the next week [maybe a few dollars higher] but still yet, you can buy without the frenzy and if it is too high and you can't afford it, you don't need it in the first place. Live within your means!! The Jones will always be with us no matter what the price, so no need to try and keep up with them. Of course, I for one am not a materialistic person, and if you want the high of Black Friday, then go for it. It's your life and your money:)))))

karen crislip of WV 3:13PM November 25, 2011

And China's economy just keeps growing and growing, and where are the jobs in America, THEY ARE IN CHINA - - and when people flock to the stores like this they support our jobs being outsourced...and NOBODY in the American lower and middle class will benefit from black Friday...

It is about big impersonal (Treat their lower class employees like crap) getting into the black, but black Friday is also about - GETTING the lower and middle class deeper and deeper into the RED - - debt to credit card companies - - it's at least a triple whammy - (1) you go out and directly support big corporations, retailers, at the expense of local businesses and restaurants....(2) you directly support the outsourcing of all American manufacturing jobs (3) and finally you put yourself into more personal debt...

and all for what - - some cheap, Chinese, tainted (look it up online tainted Chinese products) plastic crap, that has nothing to do with the best part of the holidays, Christmas (Birth of Christ? Anyone?) - and this junk, neither you nor the people you buy it for will give a crap about it after, I'd say 5 days...

Quintuple (It's a word) whammy - (4) the pollution generated by supporting the plastic behemoth that is China (5) you directly put the health of whoever you are buying this tainted crap for at risk, your kids could develop serious problems from handling many Chinese toys...

Enjoy the holidays, go fishing, go bowling, go hiking, bake with your kids, make crafts with your kids, go to museums, go see a play, read a book, go ice skating, go ride horses, BUY LOCAL - BUY AMERICAN - there are a million things to do - Don't support China to the downfall of America....

Go enjoy these with your family...learn something, enjoy the holidays, but the holidays have nothing to do with being pressured by the media, and your own emptiness and boredom to go buy a bunch of junky, tainted, plastic crap, that is ruining our environment...

Movies - For knowledge

TerrorStorm - 9-11 In Plane Sight - Loose Change - Sir, No Sir! - Winter Soldier - Hearts and Minds - White Light, Black Rain - The Panama Deception - The End of Poverty - GasHole - Who Killed The Electric Car

Movies - for fun

Trading Places - Harold and Maude - Watchmen - Hellboy - KickAss - Four Lions - V For Vendetta - Sweet and Low Down - Hot Fuzz - Eagle Vs. Shark - Black Dynamite - Being

tom of GA 1:03PM November 25, 2011

Yes, they seem to concentrate on we don't have, not on what we already have in abundance. Mix messages are sent to the public, for one, it's save money and get out of debt, pay cash for only things you need. Then they also push, buy, buy and buy! Use those credit cards. We are almost out of debt, our house is paid for, our older cars are paid for and we are now paying off our credit cards, we don't use them anymore.

Karen of IL 1:03PM November 25, 2011

Alpha Consumer

Alpha Consumer

Kimberly Palmer, senior editor for U.S. News & World Report, is the author of Generation Earn: The Young Professional's Guide to Spending, Investing, and Giving Back. Send her your personal finance questions.


advertisement

Latest Video

advertisement