Hank Paulson: How He Made the Recession Worse

January 2, 2009 RSS Feed Print

The American economy is suffering a crisis of confidence, and Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson hasn't helped, says Stanford University economist John Taylor.  Blame the TARP rollout for a worsening of the financial crisis, nto the failure to save Lehman:

While [the spread between three-month Libor and the three month Overnight Index Swap] did rise during the week following the Lehman Brothers decision, it was not far out of line with the events of the previous year.

On Friday of that week,  the Treasury announced that it was going to propose a large rescue package, though the size and details weren't there yet. Over the weekend the package was put  together and on Tuesday September 23, Federal Reserve Board Chairman Ben Bernanke and Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson testified at the Senate Banking Committee about the TARP, saying that it would be $700 billion in size. They provided a 2-1/2 page draft of legislation with no mention of oversight and few restrictions on the use. They were questioned intensely in this testimony and the reaction was quite negative, judging by the large volume of critical mail received by many members of the United States Congress. ... 

It was following this testimony that one really begins to see the crises deepening, as measured by the relentless upward movement in Libor-OIS spread for the next three weeks. Things steadily deteriorated and the spread went through the roof to 3.5 per cent. 3.2 The Lack of a Predictable Framework for Intervention

Moreover, it is plausible that events around September 23 actually drove the market, including the realization by the public that the intervention plan had not been fully thought through and that conditions were much worse than many had been led to believe. At a minimum a great deal of uncertainty about what the government would do to aid financial institutions, and under what circumstances, was revealed and thereby added to business and investment decisions at that time. Such uncertainty would have driven up risk spreads in the interbank market and elsewhere.

Reader Comments Read all comments (4)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

No one knew how bad the situation was. Try to come up with a plan when you don't even know what the problem is or the extent of it is not easy.

I think the Tarp was made flexible which was smart. There is good reason they didn't buy the bad debt. It would have cost the taxpayers a lot more $$$ and been very messy.

I think the PR around the Tarp was poorly managed.

I think the stewardship of taxpayers money was well thought out. We will probably make money on this "bailout". If you had some idiots in there throwing money left and right, the taxpayers would have lost hundreds of billions of dollars.

of IL 1:39PM January 03, 2009

What a joke. This guy is a nut! You don't solve a financial crisis by keeping the barbarians inside the gate. The barbarians are guys like Barney Franks and Chris Dodd who refused to regulate high-risk loans that sunk Fannie and Freddie. Poor regulations of high-risk debt and unregulated investment products like CDO's that sunk AIG, Lehman, Bear Stearns, and others. Bill Clinton mandated the high-risk loans!

Solve the housing makret by offering fixed 30 year 4.5% mortgage rates to good credit score borrowers with a minimum of 10% down. Let existing homeowners refinance also. That will soak up the surplus home inventory and give many people extra money to put back into the economy! The Fed has lowered interest rates to almost zero so a low mortgage rate program should allow the government to print $ and makeout like a bandit while fixing the economy at the same time. Fire Paulson!

whs806 of TX 6:39AM January 03, 2009

His plan all along was to bail out his Wall Street buddies,especially Goldman Sachs his former employer. Merely check which banks are left, to see who he helped, since he won't release the details after a FOIA request by Bloomberg, what has he got to hide?

Paulson is either incompetent, a crook or both, not a great pick for a Secretary of Treasury. I wouldn't let him manage my IRA, let alone the Treasury of the United States.

Just another in a long string of examples of incompetent people in high places acting incompetently in the Bush administration. We are lucky the country is still relatively intact after the last 8 years of dubious decisions and outright looting, ie Haliburtons no bid contract on Iraq.

Dick Cheney of WY 4:40PM January 02, 2009

Capital Commerce

Capital Commerce

U.S. News business reporter Matthew Bandyk examines the issues, people, and debates that shape the nexus of political and economic life in the nation's capital.

advertisement

advertisement