Does The Credit Card Bill Of Rights Mean More Consumer Freedom, Or Less?

July 20, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (8)

Back when the Credit CARD Act (also known as the Credit Cardholder's Bill of Rights) was being debated, opponents argued that the bill would not stop "abuses" of customers by credit card companies, but rather simply shift their efforts in ways that limit consumer choice.

Now, the Consumerist blog has reported all the new ways that credit card companies are trying to wring as much money out of as they can before the new rules come into place. This is a few days old, but I think it's important to note something. The blog post seems to hint that these new "mean" practices will go away when the new legislation takes effect. While most of these new practices will be regulated by the CARD Bill starting in February of 2010, it also seems that in some cases, the CARD Bill is creating new difficulties that it does nothing to stop.

Overall standards are becoming more stringent for riskier customers.

"Lets say you owe 40k in debt, and your last reported household income is 50k. Well, if you already owe 40k, and you only make 50k, how are you ever going to pay that back? So the bank is dropping the line because they don't feel they'll ever get repaid if they give it to you. You cant default on another 10k if they don't let you have it in the first place."

Why? As David John of the Heritage Foundation told me in my story on the subject:

"The bill reduces the opportunity for credit card issuers to cover their own costs on certain higher-risk categories," says David John...

If they can't cover their costs on those high-risk people, then they will take fewer risks. If that quote from the Consumerist blog is accurate, we are already seeing fewer credit opportunities as a result.

Reader Comments Read all comments (8)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

It's nearly impossible to rent a car, buy an airline ticket, make a hotel reservation, buy a snack on an airplane, or rent a $1 DVD at the supermarket without a credit card. Who wants to charge a $1? Credit Cards are required for living in American Society. Candidly, the system is rigged.

If businesses valued cash transactions as much as credit card sales, as a country we probably wouldn't have the amount of personal debt that has been accrued by many Americans. Changing our attitudes about credit is the first step to a healthier purse. Credit is not necessarily a good thing. It can lead to a frightening chain resulting in personal disaster.

The Credit Card Bill of Rights gives the consumer the opportunity to have a level playing field. Starting in February, the credit card industry has new rules in an old game. Maybe if we change our own personal rules and pay with cash as we go, the game will go into a timeout.

Susan of VA 6:33AM December 22, 2009

How do we make it work for the CC and us? Obviously, we need to work together: for us to spend and for them to make money. But it seems it is a win/lose not a win/win situation. What are some possible answers?

J. Bannister of FL 5:04PM July 26, 2009

The credit card bill of rights is a Joke. What next Wright your own loan bill of rights

This so called bill of rights is a platform to keep you enslaved the to the beckon call of the credit card company.

Unless the credit card bill of rights goes something like this

1. You have the Right to pay off your card without penalty

2. You have the Right to never use a credit card again.

3. You have the Right to STOP encroachment to use the credit card, from. Company.

4. You have the Right to live without need to, have to have a credit card. Just cut the thing up and be done with that debt.

Since your local governments don’t have the Gaul to protect you, learn to live without it. Hum, hum, you see what your Bank card is starting to do to you. So What Rights, do you really think you will get.

Oley Pub Opion of GA 1:52PM July 25, 2009

Capital Commerce

U.S. News business reporter Matthew Bandyk examines the issues, people, and debates that shape the nexus of political and economic life in the nation's capital.

advertisement

advertisement