Are Social Conservatives Holding Back Economic Conservatives?

November 9, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (6)

The national debate has been all about economics recently. While the conventional wisdom is that economic issues tend to favor the Democrats in the realm of public opinion, there is at least some evidence that complaints about the economy and Obama's plan to fix it helped fuel the GOP victories in Virginia and New Jersey last week. And as I blogged about last week, conservatives' shift to the right on economics has led to the decidedly-unconservative Ayn Rand being annointed as a GOP idol.

But maybe Republicans aren't getting as much mileage from their economic arguments as they could. A recent article in the Nation looks at how young conservatives are turned off by some of the extremes of the party.

While these young conservatives may not present silver-bullet solutions to the GOP's woes, they believe rebuilding the party shouldn't take a back seat to birthers, deathers and the rest of the far-right fringe. David Laska, the 22-year-old president of New York University College Republicans, says, "We need to start paying less attention to the Tom Tancredo wing of the Republican Party. I don't think that wing of the party is as big as some people make it out it be."

What this article never explictly says—but hints at through the interviews with young conservatives—is that it's the issues where Republicans stray from free-market principles—like immigration or gay marriage—that turn the youth off.

Will these young people become more socially conservative as they get older, or have we reached a point where free-market economics is the only issue Republicans can use to capture the minds of rising generations?

Reader Comments Read all comments (6)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

One more thing: opposing illegal immigration is hardly "extreme," as this is supported by young and old alike, and not just conservatives.

For example, a Zogby Interactive Survey from November of 2008 showed that 45% of respondents age 18-24 agreed that reducing illegal immigration, securing the borders, and cracking down on employers who hire illegals was still important to them as it was the previous year (compared to 13.5% who thought it was less so). This compared to 33.9% from the same group who believed it was still important to them to legalize illegal immigrants as it was the previous year.

Joe of PA 7:59PM November 13, 2009

So the author quotes The Nation to talk about conservatives. How silly.

Regarding illegal immigration, the vast majority of Americans oppose "comprehensive immigration reform" a/k/a mass amnesty, so this issue is in no way holding back the conservative movement.

And if we legalized illegal aliens, this would impose a net burden of at least $2.6 TRILLION on taxpayers (per the Heritage Foundation, 2007 amnesty bill estimate) and grow government. How would this impact the free market Bandyk?

Joe of PA 4:39PM November 13, 2009

Conservatives. Understand the morality of reason and capitalism. Start with something that exists - existance, and make a choice to live. The rest will follow. Be radicals for what you know to be right.

These are the tools to fight unreason and its political expression socialism, now pervading the planet.

Don Rowberry

New Zealand

Don Rowberry 6:42PM November 10, 2009

Capital Commerce

U.S. News business reporter Matthew Bandyk examines the issues, people, and debates that shape the nexus of political and economic life in the nation's capital.

advertisement

advertisement