Why a Rising Unemployment Rate is Good News

May 7, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (69)

It sounds dreadful. After drifting down consistently since last fall, the unemployment rate has suddenly shot up again, from 9.7 percent in March to 9.9 percent in April. But don't despair: A rising unemployment rate is actually one of the best signs yet that the economy is bouncing back.

[See 7 new rules for getting ahead.]

The unemployment rate rose for the right reason. Instead of shedding jobs, employers added 290,000 jobs in April, the strongest showing since 2007. The reason the unemployment rate went up is that a lot more people are suddenly looking for work. The government said that the labor force swelled by 805,000 people in April. That's more than three times the number of new jobs, so the proportion of people looking for a job but unable to find one went up. Still, that big increase in the labor force marks an important shift in sentiment among people on the fringes of the economy.

One of the most worrisome trends throughout the recession and early stages of the recovery has been the declining size of the U.S. labor force itself. By late last year, so many unemployed people had given up looking for a job that the labor force participation rate—the percent of adults who either have a job or are looking for one—had fallen to a 25-year low. Others who might have entered the labor force—recent graduates, stay-at-home spouses—decided not to. The government considers the labor force to include everybody who either has a job or is looking for one. So if you get laid off and spend your days hunting for a new job, you count as part of the labor force, even if you're not earning a paycheck. But if you get discouraged and give up, you don't count.

[See what's going right and wrong with the economy.]

Until recently, the ranks of "discouraged workers" who had given up looking for jobs had been swelling at alarming rates. Now, a long-term decline in the labor force participation rate finally seems to be reversing, as more people decide that it might be worth looking for a job after all. The participation rate bottomed out last December, when just 64.6 percent of working-age adults belonged to the labor force. It ticked upward for the first three months of 2010, and now it has risen to 65.2 percent. Before the recession, it hovered above 66 percent, so there's still a way to go. But the mere fact that long-unemployed people are looking for work again is encouraging.

One reason economists worry about a "jobless recovery" is that people who have been out of work for a long time find it extremely difficult to rejoin the working world, even as the economy recovers. They tend to lose touch with workplace trends, miss out on new skills, and simply become unmotivated. It might be tempting to write off the long-term unemployed as dropouts, except that not long ago they were productive workers who earned money and contributed to economic growth. Consigning them to the sidelines depresses the economy—and adds more weight to a social safety net that's already frayed.

[See how to plan for a slow-motion recovery.]

About 195,000 formerly discouraged workers have now reentered the labor force, presumably because they think the chances of finding a job are getting better. That's a tiny fraction of the 6.7 million Americans who count as the long-term unemployed, but it's still a break in the gloom. Another 610,000 people entered the labor force without being technically unemployed, a sign that first-time workers and other job seekers have decided to get off the couch and start hustling. There are a lot more where they came from, which means the unemployment rate might still rise in future months, before it turns around and starts declining for good. For once, it will be something to cheer.

Tags:
Bureau of Labor Statistics,
employment,
unemployment

Reader Comments Read all comments (69)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

The prooblem is not only the lack of jobs but companies continue to layoff with massive cuts as more and more jobs continue to head overseas. There are very few entry level jobs left in the United States. For every job that goes overseas, that's one less person that has money to buy a new car, or perhaps your home, or cable tv, or a cell phone, or buy the newspaper, or go to the mall and shop, or go out to eat, or pay taxes to the government! When jobs are lost everyone is affected. Just because unemployment is sky high doesn't mean the economy is turning around.

Rick of FL 10:12AM July 23, 2011

Yes as I read in one of the blog http://www.mikeastrachan.com/ there was a contradiction between household survey and payroll survey. According to payroll survey it is said that there is decrease in employment rate but just opposite in household survey. Unemployment rate is decreasing is some way or other.

Nikki of AL 8:55AM December 01, 2010

A Depression is not measured by the GDP or the level of the stock market. If you check these charts from the 1929 Depression (1929-1945) you will see that

after a short periiod of time (1929-1932) they did recover. But they wealth of the

general population was in decline. Which is the situation here. Multi-national corporations are doing just fine. They have at least one trillion dollars in savings

while America's citizens are broke and struggling. The value of their largest investment, home, have lost 30-40% of it's value and there is a job shortage at every salary level. It is high time the US has backed out of NAFTA, foreign aid, tax incentives to hire labor over seas, increased immigration, the selling of American corporation overseas, out sourcing, etc. These sweet heart deals have destroyed the

American way of life. The special interest groups and companies have the US people and national economic security by the throat. Without the economic strength of the American people our democracy will die. It will belong to the special interest groups and multi-national corporations. The US must reverse the economic policies of the past decades.

George Orwell of PA 3:22PM September 07, 2010

Rick Newman

Rick Newman

The global economy is mysterious, even scary. Chief Business Correspondent Rick Newman connects the dots. In addition to his writing for U.S. News, Rick is the co-author of two books: Firefight: Inside the Battle to Save the Pentagon on 9/11, and Bury Us Upside Down: The Misty Pilots and the Secret Battle for the Ho Chi Minh Trail.


Read Rick's latest blog entries here.

advertisement

advertisement