Best and Worst of the Little Books

March 26, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (2)

There are now so many books in the "Little Book" investment series that it's hard to keep them straight. Luckily, someone has done that for me. Here, the Simple Dollar reviews all five books and weighs in on the best and worst of the bunch.

John Bogle's The Little Book of Common Sense Investing wins for "best investing advice," thanks to its simple premise of investing in index funds. "Bogle's is really the only one yet that has truly convinced me of the benefits of that strategy," says Simple Dollar. Chris Browne's The Little Book of Value Investing gets a nod for "most worthwhile read," because it's essentially a more easily digestible presentation of the concepts in Benjamin Graham's The Intelligent Investor.

The "worst entry" of the series is the original: Joel Greenblatt's The Little Book That Beats the Market. The book, says Simple Dollar, "only really succeeds in one respect: It explains in extremely simple terms how the stock market works. After that, it gets into an investment strategy that seems to be flaky at best." Tell that to the 2,759 devotees of Greenblatt's "Magic Formula" approach on this Yahoo Group.

Of the two remaining books in the series, The Little Book That Builds Wealth and The Little Book That Makes You Rich, "both do good jobs of laying out their specific strategies and are good follow-ups to The Little Book of Value Investing in that they can provide a great background on specific individual stock-picking strategies," says Simple Dollar. Got all that?

Tags:
investing,
books

Reader Comments Read all comments (2)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

He is looking to get at the same stocks that the Browne book does and Dorsey's book for that matter....He also tells you that there maybe times (long stretches - 3 years) that the method will be painful to follow. Another of his points is that you can do well with the small caps as well as large caps with his formula. But I would suggest staying above the $1B market cap with the Magic Formula (unless you have a steel stomach). Greenblatt also says you should probably research further the stocks selected in the screen. I enjoyed them all .... for my family's portfolio ... its a Bogle method ... for me it's Bogle as the base and my fun money goes with Greenblatt for the screen and Browne for the analysis on the screen. I might take into consideration what Dorsey and Naveiller have to say in order to narrow down my companies.

Oracle of Grandview of MO 11:07PM March 30, 2008

Is flaky? come on! All strategies underperform from time to time. what's wrong with buying good companies at cheap prices?

Seems like you are the flaky one here; posting opinions without sound reasoning

confused of MI 1:04PM March 27, 2008

Money Matters

Katy Marquardt came to U.S. News from Kiplinger's Personal Finance magazine, where she profiled rising stars in the mutual-fund world and wrote about investing in stocks and racehorses. Katy hails from Abilene, Texas, and graduated from the University of Texas-Austin.

Kirk Shinkle is a senior editor at U.S. News. Formerly, he covered business and economics on both coasts for Investor's Business Daily. A native of the Montana-Texas corridor, he currently resides in the wilds of west Brooklyn. His checkered online evolution looks like this: Friendster, still (!). MySpace, no. Facebook, yes. He blogs here, Twitters occasionally, and has yet to Tumblr.

advertisement

advertisement