Are Nonemployer Businesses Really Entrepreneurial?

April 6, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (1)
Scott Shane

Scott Shane

One of the difficult statistics for entrepreneurship researchers to understand is the vast majority of people who run their own businesses but have no employees. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, in 2002 (the latest year for which data are available publicly), there were 23.3 million firms in operation in the United States. However, only 5.7 million of them (24.4 percent) were employer firms. That is, three quarters of U.S. entrepreneurs had no employees.

Moreover, most of these nonemployer businesses are truly tiny. According to the Census Department data, U.S. firms generated $22.8 trillion in revenue in 2002. But less than 3.4 percent of this revenue came from nonemployer firms. The average revenue of a nonemployer firm in 2002 was only $45,000.

Some observers ask if the owners of these nonemployer businesses are really entrepreneurs. For instance, the Census Bureau argues that most of these nonemployer businesses are sideline efforts among people whose primary job involves working for someone else.

If the owners of nonemployer businesses aren't entrepreneurs, that raises an interesting dilemma. Because nonemployer businesses account for a large share of the businesses in this country, if you don't count the owners of nonemployer businesses, then there are far fewer entrepreneurs in this country than we currently estimate. With 5.7 million employer businesses in a country of close to 288 million people (in 2002), we have just shy of 2 employer businesses per 100 people, as opposed to 8 businesses per 100 people, overall.

Scott Shane is A. Malachi Mixon III professor of entrepreneurial studies at Case Western Reserve University. He is the author of Illusions of Entrepreneurship: The Costly Myths That Entrepreneurs, Investors, and Policy Makers Live By, among other books.

Tags:
entrepreneurship,
small business

Reader Comments Read all comments (1)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Your interpretation of the data matches my analysis of US Census Bureau and SBA/IRS statistics. Interpreting the statistics are not hard. Basic math right?

However, I am puzzled. It seems that every time our state and federal government legislators are in session, they are adding more difficulty for entrepreneurs to start or expand firms. In short, we don't have a lack of jobs in the USA. We have a lack of entrepreneurs.

What does this say about the education system in the USA? Basically, the only education widely distributed is how to be an employee. Very little training can be found through our public education system on how to be an entrepreneur.

Could this lead to the failure of our economy and the necessity of socialism? Think about about it. Less than 2% of the population creates the jobs for 98% of the population. The vast majority of our populace don't know how to (or is afraid to) be self reliant, self motivated, or self supportive.

Tony Bass of GA 5:16AM February 06, 2011

Outside Voices: Small Business

Read commentary about the day-to-day of running a small business from some of the top bloggers in the small business community.

advertisement

advertisement