Survey: Employees Want Fewer 401(k) Decisions

February 17, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (2)

The typical 401(k) plan has about 18 investment options. Savvy and inexperienced investors alike are expected to choose among them. Account holders must also individually calculate how much they must tuck away each year to finance an unknown number of retirement years. It turns out that many workers would prefer not to have that responsibility.

[See New Details of Obama’s Automatic IRA Proposal.]

The majority of employees don’t want to decide how much they need to save in a 401(k) and how to invest their retirement stash. A recent Prudential survey found that many workers (70 percent) would be pleased if their employer automatically enrolled them in the company’s retirement account. And more than half of respondents (60 percent) would prefer that their employers fully automate retirement accounts so they don’t have to make any 401(k) decisions at all.

[See Should Saving for Retirement be Required?]

The survey of 1,010 full time employees with a retirement plan at work found that 70 percent think the decisions they need to make to participate in their 401(k) are complicated. Almost half (48 percent) of the workers sought guidance from their employers to make savings and investment decisions. But 39 percent of those workers thought the plan materials they received actually make it more difficult to make 401(k) choices. Many workers said the handouts were not the correct length or detail and that the guides and tools were difficult to understand.

“Today’s workers recognize the critical role played by their employment based retirement plan and are keenly aware that the existing do-it-yourself approach simply isn’t the best way to build or achieve retirement security,” says Christine Marcks, president of Prudential Retirement. “Workers seem comfortable giving up a level of control if it might mean the potential for better outcomes over the long term.”

[See How Automatic Enrollment Affects Your 401(k) Match.]

The Prudential survey found that workers generally had a positive impression of auto-pilot retirement programs including automatic enrollment in retirement accounts (74 percent), periodic contribution increases (65 percent), and automatic asset-allocation (58 percent).

Tell us, would you prefer that someone else make your retirement account decisions?

Tags:
retirement

Reader Comments Read all comments (2)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Actually, instead of fewer choices, I would prefer being able to link to ING (Sharebuilder) for greater diversity in picking dividend stocks. Our plan at work, while excellent, compared to other plans doesn't have enough "safe" investments to me. I lost nearly 50% in 2007-2008. We only have one bond fund and one guaranteed fund (at about 1%). So...basically you are earning nothing. I also think we should be able to buy treasury bonds via payroll deduction just as another option to the current plan. You can do this on-line; however, the changes made by the Treasury Department have made doing so almost impossible. You have to key in so many codes. Oh well...something beats nothing that's for sure. And who can trust officers who manage large pension funds. They are subject to bad choices just like everybody else. You would have a small group of individuals making decisions on your behalf.

kaybtt of CA 4:22PM February 18, 2010

Americans are, apparently, willing to give up a lot of their freedoms. But to give up the freedom to make important decisions about your own financial future--which means having as many choices of investments as possible--is truly sad. Making good, well-diversified financial decisions does require a little reading, a little effort, and a regular schedule to research and pay attention to those investments. But that's a small price to pay for knowing about and protecting your future. Researching stocks and mutual funds is easy to do on the Internet through many respectable, responsible sites like Fidelity, E-Trade, and Morningstar.

To me the stupidity of people who say what this article claims that they are saying would be the equivalent of letting someone pick the food that you eat and the doctor that you will go to. Those decisions, too, are critical to your future.

Americans had best wake up. We haven't been defeated in battle because of the bravery of our military, but we can easily cause the country, as well as our own financial futures to collapse if we are unwilling to do a little work and make the effort. Knowing something about finance is essential to be successful and to educate and raise your family.

By the way, we saw exactly what happened in 2009 to many people who put all their money in their company's stock. They lost it all. The number one rule of investing--diversification.

Sherlock Holmes of NH 3:18PM February 18, 2010

Planning to Retire

Senior editor Emily Brandon tells you how to get ready financially for retirement and to make your golden years the best they can be.

advertisement

Our retirement readiness calculator will provide a rough idea of how long your retirement savings and income will last.


advertisement