7 Reasons Americans Can’t Save for Retirement

February 23, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (13)

Americans are increasingly making an effort to save for retirement, but they’re finding it difficult to build a significant nest egg. “There are indications that many Americans are trying to meet the challenge of saving for their future,” says Dallas Salisbury, president of the Employee Benefit Research Institute. However, less than half (47 percent) of current workers say they are saving enough to have a desirable standard of living in retirement, according to a new America Saves and American Savings Education Council survey conducted by Opinion Research Corp. Here’s a look at why most workers aren’t on track to retire comfortably.

[See Older Worker Employment Reaches Record High.]

Living beyond our means. The first step toward saving for retirement is to spend less than what you earn. But a quarter of workers say they are not saving because they spend all of their income. Most people say they are saving between 1 and 10 percent of their income (47 percent) or more than 10 percent (25 percent).

Little employer help. Only about half (54 percent) of those surveyed save for retirement at work using a 401(k) or other retirement account. Many middle class workers are not gaining pay increases, while they are being asked to increase their health insurance contributions and receiving lower retirement account contributions from their employer, says Stephen Brobeck, executive director of the Consumer Federation of America. “Compared to last year, more Americans are finding it difficult to achieve savings progress.”

Not saving automatically. Even fewer workers (44 percent) save automatically outside of a workplace retirement account by making regular preauthorized transfers from their checking account to a savings or investment account. “Many people find that once they set up an automatic savings plan that puts a small portion of their income directly into a separate account, they never miss it, and the savings helps them build the future they want,” says Nancy Register, director of America Saves.

[See 10 Bargain Retirement Spots.]

Too much debt. It’s even more difficult to save for the future when you are still paying off past purchases. Only about a third (37 percent) of those surveyed are completely debt free. Most Americans are working on reducing their debt (42 percent) or have debt that they are unable to reduce or that is still growing (20 percent). About two-thirds of the survey respondents own property, typically with a mortgage (42 percent). Most people with mortgage debt (75 percent) plan to pay it off before retirement.

Savings isn’t a priority. Many current expenses and debts are prioritized above saving for retirement. Just over half (57 percent) of Americans say they have a specific savings goal. And only 54 percent of those surveyed know their net worth.

No emergency fund. An emergency fund of cash outside your retirement account is essential to avoid dipping into your nest egg—and paying the resulting taxes and fees—when you experience a sudden large expense. However, 30 percent of those surveyed say they don’t have sufficient emergency savings to pay for unexpected expenses such as car repairs or a doctor visit. “You don’t have to make a lot of money to have the ability to save,” says James McIntire, Washington's State Treasurer. “Saving $5 each and every week over time can help provide the financial security needed for the future.”

[See 4 Cautionary Tales for Retirees.]

Spending windfalls. About half of Americans say they sometimes receive financial windfalls, including tax refunds, gifts, and bonuses. Most people who receive a cash windfall (39 percent) save at least part of it, but 10 percent generally spend it all. Catherine Smith, CEO of ING U.S. Retirement Services, says workers should save the 2 percent reduction in Social Security taxes in 2011 for retirement. “We’re encouraging employees to give themselves a retirement raise by saving this extra income in their retirement plan,” she says. “Even a 1 or 2 percent increase can help grow your savings account significantly over time.”

Twitter: @aiming2retire

Tags:
retirement

Reader Comments Read all comments (13)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I am a widow and at 60 I could receive Widows SS off my late husband but it barely pays the mortgage. I can't work without paying taxes and can't earn over a specified amount or the SS benefit is lessened. Between a rock and a hard place to make ends meet. Yet illegal immigrants don't have to follow our rules.....and this is without even mentioning health care costs at age 62.....America why can't we help OUR OWN ???

E Schneider of NY 8:11PM May 09, 2013

Doesn't take a genius financial person to figure out why people aren't saving. Reading the comments tells me that people working in this country, paying taxes and not mooching the system all have the same problem as middle class Americans. Salaries don't give us enough money to live on with the cost of living so ridiculous. It would be interesting to see the percentage of Americans working 2 and 3 jobs just to make ends meet. It would probably be shocking.

Of course, any of these bozo's that are making laws and trying to tell us what we should be doing aren't living with a terrible income like some of us have to.

Another comment....stay out of these stuupid religious wars we're getting into. WE CAN'T AFFORD TO HELP ALL THESE COUNTRIES ANYMORE if your going to tax us to death. They don't help us with anything. How many other countries showed up during the New York hurricane or the New Orleans disaster or any other disaster our country has. No one to my knowledge. Knock it off. Let them fend for themselves for awhile till we get back on our feet if we ever do. It all makes me sick.

Sharri Paige of MN 2:47PM April 01, 2013

While the intentions of the author is to educate the reader I think this synopsis of the 7 Reasons are breath and not depth. These are the easy reasons, not the more difficult ones (I mean no offense here). This article could have been 1 Reason and expanded on the "Little Employer Help". There is no denying Americans have too much debt, no denying we don't save enough and that we lack knowledge on how to manage our money. Yet, employers have shifted more responsibility and benefit expenses upon their employees and kept their wages relatively flat compared to senior executive salaries. CEO's have very little difficulty retiring. Expand upon why employers are of little help and I believe the shift to these 7 reasons will expand accordingly.

Evan Cole of CA 1:48PM March 31, 2013

Planning to Retire

Senior editor Emily Brandon tells you how to get ready financially for retirement and to make your golden years the best they can be.

advertisement

Our retirement readiness calculator will provide a rough idea of how long your retirement savings and income will last.


advertisement