Is Homeownership the Best Long-Term Investment?

April 20, 2011 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (5)

Most adults (81 percent) agree that buying a home is the best long-term investment a person can make, according a Pew Research Center survey of 2,142 adults released this month. But confidence in homeownership as a path to prosperity is declining. The number of people who strongly agree that homeownership is the best investment a person can make has declined from 49 percent in 1991 to 37 percent in 2011.

[See the 10 Best Places for the Wealthiest Retirees.]

Most homeowners are happy with their choice. Some 76 percent of homeowners agree that they would buy their present house again, despite the fact that 47 percent say their house is now worth less than it was in December 2007. Less than a quarter (24 percent) of renters rent by choice. Most people who rent apartments say they rent as a result of life circumstances (75 percent) and would like to buy a house at some point in the future (81 percent).

Despite falling home prices, young people continue to be priced out of the housing market. Most Americans (66 percent) say that homeownership is unaffordable for young adults in their 20s and 30s. Only 15 percent of people under 30 own a home. The rest rent (46 percent), live with their parents (27 percent), or reside in a college dorm (6 percent). However, a majority of people 30 and over (70 percent) say they own their own home.

[See What Retirement Savings Tax Breaks Cost Us.]

Adults age 65 and older and those who have lived in their current home for over 30 years are the most confident about the investment value of homeownership, typically because they have paid off their mortgage. Younger and newer homeowners are more skeptical about whether housing will prove to be a solid long-term investment, the telephone survey conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates International found. Some 57 percent of the survey respondents own a home, 30 percent are renters, and the rest have other living arrangements.

[See How to Save for Retirement on a Low Income.]

Homeownership and being able to live comfortably in retirement were both rated as important long-term financial goals by 80 percent of the survey respondents. Other common long-term financial objectives include paying for their children’s college education (73 percent) and leaving an inheritance to children (53 percent).

Twitter: @aiming2retire

Tags:
retirement

Reader Comments Read all comments (5)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

I understand both sides of the coin.

I bought my house in my early 30's with a 30 yr. mortgage, after one year, refinanced to a 15yr. mtg. Payments still high, but will be mortgage free soon. I expected to raise my family here, and then sell when ready to retire.

Buy a condo or something small, but..... I live on Long Island where the taxes have increased dramatically every year since I been here. I don't see any relief in sight. Even if I didn't have a mortgage the taxes and cost of living is insane. Forget about long term retirement, I am afraid of being pushed out before I can finish paying off my place. Any advice? I really don't want to lose all I have invested so far.

Laura of NY 11:27AM May 28, 2011

As "Thorton Mellon" said in Back to School...."Oh you left out a bunch of stuff".

First, for renters, rental expenses come every month for the rest of your life. And secondly, they will increase each and every year for the rest of your life. Whereas, the homeowner will have FIXED payments for a maximum of 30 years and then only have the property taxes, maintenance and insurance costs to pay annually for the remainder of their life (which represent roughly 3% of the hoem value). Owners of rental properties usually charge rents at basically the equivalent amount that an owner would pay on the same property. Afterall, the investor must cover the cost of the loan, maintenance, insurance, and property taxes. Those costs are passed on to the renter (or will be when markets equalize) or the investor will not invest.

Secondly, lets look at a renter who pays $900 a month per year vs a homeonwer who pays $1000 month PIMI mortgage. In 15 years, the renter will likely be paying $1550 a month and the homeowner will be paying the same $1000. You want opportunity costs? How about the opportunity to save $550 a month over renters? Thats $6600 a year in cash. Add compund interest on that and it grows pretty big. At the 30 year mark, the homeowner will be paying just the taxes, maintenance, and insurance, roughly $300 a month, while your renter is likely now paying $2800 a month. NOw, I know home values may go down but we are not talking about home values unless you intend to sell. Then it is a different story.

Third, homeowners have an asset they can rightlfully use as collateral in a loan that your would be renter could not use. So, while that renter who wants a loan for other investments is paying 9%-20% for an unsecured loan, our nifty homeowner is borrowing off his asset for 4%-9%. That 9% annual rate the renter is paying is quite a big hurdle to overcome in any investment before you start to break even. But I will give you credit, you are paying interest on your own money so to speak. But you chose to transfer your cash to a physical asset, and there is a cost to change it back into cash....thats the interest.

Bryan of IN 8:05PM May 25, 2011

I am single and now retired and I do not want this POS house anymore. I want to sell it, pay off the bank OR just give it to the bank and head south, way south. Like to South America. Live there under cheap rent and cheap cost of living for 3 years then go to Thailand for 3 years and then maybe to China for a year.. get my drift. I think living in this fashion specially being single, you will live longer and be more happy than listen to all the crappy goings on the TUBE everyday. This country has became very sick and needs to heal which I do not see happening in my lifetime. SO ESCAPE is the only way.

Andre of MI 4:00PM May 25, 2011

Planning to Retire

Senior editor Emily Brandon tells you how to get ready financially for retirement and to make your golden years the best they can be.

advertisement

Our retirement readiness calculator will provide a rough idea of how long your retirement savings and income will last.


advertisement