Are Weekends Necessary?

July 14, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (3)

The Best Buy ROWE (Results Only Work Environment) has a lot of things going for it. Employees want more flexibility, but employers can't afford to lower expectations. In a ROWE—as developed by the authors of Why Work Sucks and How to Fix It—the worker can decide when, where, and how he or she works, so long as the work gets done.

But doesn't the elimination of weekends kind of take it too far? Harvard Business Review contributor Tammy Erickson says mandated days of rest are antiquated:

Let's talk some more about redesigning our organizations—"hacking" the enterprise. Here's another fundamental assumption upon which our organizations are built that I think has got to go: weekends.

No, I'm not arguing that we should all work seven days a week. But I do think that the idea of a corporation telling us which days to work (and when to "rest") is outdated.

It seems to me that commerce is about more than work—it's about forging community ties and sharing responsibilities. Companies that lack collective days of rest lose out on the communal aspects of relaxation and labor—the natural rhythms that drive our gearing up and shifting down. The buildup of anticipation on Fridays and the charged focus of Monday mornings are generally shared experiences that create collaboration in often isolated work environments. Am I wrong?

Tags:
careers,
corporate culture

Reader Comments Read all comments (3)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

You seem to want it both ways. Yes to shared experiences, but No to collusion.

I noticed that your last 26 entries were all submitted on weekdays. Not one article on a Saturday or a Sunday.

Hmmmm.

jbenson2 of MN 5:58PM July 14, 2008

Not only are you right about the communal aspect, but I've found that, when you agree to odd-shift hours, you tend to find that you're indispensible for emergencies that crop up on your days off. There's a reason we all work (generally) the same hours: we work together. You cannot get anything done in corporate America without a consensus, and getting a consensus when you're in the office alone is not a good thing.

A few other reasons this is an incredibly bad idea:

Resources: most office buildings go without heat/AC, lighting, water, garbage collection, etc. on weekends. These costs are generally a per-day thing, not a per-employee thing (unless you mandate an entire floor take off on the same day). Adding two more days to the facilities budget would increase costs by, roughly, 40%. And that's only if you limit the building to being open 9-5 on Saturday and Sunday.

Families: Would we extend this "flexible workweek" to schools? If not, how many parents do you think will choose to take a day off when their kids are in school?

Renovations/Maintenance: Similar to resources, when would you have the office repaired? When would you have the cleaning staff vacuum the floors and clean the bathrooms and empty the trash? These things get in the way during the day, which is why they are universally done during off hours.

Dan of NY 5:46PM July 14, 2008

I'm interning for the summer at a company where working from home is quickly catching on. While it is welcomed by most, I feel as someone who is new to the organization, I definitely lose out on the communal aspect of the work culture. Most of my time is spent listening/talking to people on phone meetings without ever meeting them in person! For me, commerce is more than work for sure.

Fatema of MD 1:30PM July 14, 2008

The Inside Job

You're taking a break from your job-hunting and job-hopping ways and have decided to stay put in your current position. Liz Wolgemuth’s careers blog will show you how to make the very best of your job, each day.

advertisement

advertisement