Layoff Trends: NYT vs. WSJ

March 4, 2009 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (2)

Earlier this week, political strategist Mark Penn wrote in the Wall Street Journal that the newest recessionary microtrend is layoffs of professionals--lawyers and doctors and the like. While "America has been losing manufacturing jobs for decades," it's now seeing a new phenomenon of the "wholesale loss of professional jobs," Penn writes.

Penn laments that these professionals "worked and studied hard to get to the next level in life, only to have their jobs and careers wiped out along with so many others."

Today, in the New York Times, we read this:

Unlike the last two recessions--earlier this decade and in the early 1990s--this one is causing much more job loss among the less educated than among college graduates. Those earlier recessions introduced the country to the concept of mass white-collar layoffs. The brunt of the layoffs in this recession is falling on construction workers, hotel workers, retail workers and others without a four-year degree.

College grads 25 years and older may take comfort that their unemployment rate is just 3.8 percent compared to the national average of 7.6 percent. The unemployment rate for workers 25 years and older who didn't graduate high school is 12 percent. For high school grads (again, 25 and older), it's 8 percent, and 6.2 percent for those who have had some college education.

But those numbers don't tell us much about the effects of this recession. Here's a look at the percent change in the number of unemployed between January 2008 and January 2009:

Non-high school grad: up 54 percent

High school grad: up 74 percent

Some college: up 70 percent

College grad: up 85 percent

Tags:
careers

Reader Comments Read all comments (2)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

As I understand it, there are a limited number of “professions” in the technical sense.

They are defined by a combination of a standard curriculum that makes up their required professional degree and regulation by a professional body that provides examinations and require a license to practice upon completion of the degree (or completion of the degree combined with a specified number of years of experience in the field).

The classic example of this would be the law and the bar association, but others include medicine and dentistry or architecture which requires a state by state license to sign drawings.

The idea is that if you are studying medicine for example you will be required to study the same material in a core curriculum at any med school across the country.

I agree with you. As a designer not a licensed architect I was often put off by this use of the word “professional” before I was corrected and learned its actual meaning.

It is tricky because the word “professional” is used to describe just about anyone who is paid to do a job. Of course I still consider myself a design professional even though design my area of design is not technically a “profession”.

Hope this helps.

LS of NY 2:03PM March 06, 2009

The first question I've always had about this sort of thing is, "What is a 'professional'?" You're a professional journalist; I'm a professional computer scientist; someone else may be a professional bricklayer or a professional retail sales rep. The WSJ clearly makes a distinction between lawyers, doctors, and others of their class as "professionals", and others of a lesser class, a distinction that I find offensive and unnecessary.

But to the point: in my industry -- computer and information technology -- workforce reductions have, for the last fifteen or twenty years, affected us. The "layoffs" have included many "professionals" with college degrees, with PhDs, with whatever schooling you might consider. The current round is no different, as I see it from here. We might not be affected as much as, say, construction workers. But we're affected now, as before.

Barry Leiba of NY 4:56PM March 04, 2009

The Inside Job

You're taking a break from your job-hunting and job-hopping ways and have decided to stay put in your current position. Liz Wolgemuth’s careers blog will show you how to make the very best of your job, each day.

advertisement

advertisement