SEC Commissioner: More Financial Regulation Not Needed

New rules on hedge funds, transparency could have harmful, unintended consequences.


SEC Chairman Christopher Cox (R) talks with SEC Commissioner Paul Atkins during a House Financial Services Committee hearing.

By + More

The recent volatility in the investment markets has revealed the effects of a boom in unregulated investments such as hedge funds, derivatives, and commercial paper. Some observers say the failure of some bonds backed by subprime mortgages has roiled many distantly related investments only because investors don't have enough information to see just how serious the mortgage problems are—something a little regulation could fix. Even Christopher Cox, the Republican chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, and no fan of overregulation, asked Congress this summer for the power to make municipal bond issuers provide more information. But in an interview with U.S. News, SEC Commissioner Paul Atkins, also a Republican, argues against more intrusion into the markets. The markets will get over these troubles on their own, he believes.

Are you worried about the market today?

Obviously, there's been some volatility in the marketplace lately. That's part of what makes it interesting. It's not like putting money into a bank. The risks are higher, and so are the potential rewards. We like to preach around here, as do a lot of people, that people should invest for the long term. If you look over any long stretch of time, the equity markets, at least, have been producing a return that is better than other alternatives. So that's what you have to keep in mind.

So do you think this is just sort of a short-term ripple, and this will work itself out?

Well, one never knows, but if you look at the recent actions of the Federal Reserve and some of the other central banks, and the reaction of our marketplace, yeah, I think the marketplace has taken it more or less in stride. There will be changes of business models. People will start to react to what has happened in how they allocate their investments.... But I think we on the regulatory side and elsewhere can't become panicked. We have to look at the long term as to how we set policy and how we react to the market's ups and downs.... This will work itself out, ultimately.

One of the complaints from investors is that all kinds of investments are getting beaten down because people don't know where the risks really are. Do you think there is a lack of transparency in the market, and if so, is that a problem?

That's a complicated question. First, if you are looking at the retail market, if you are a normal investor, corporations are required to disclose to you in a prospectus [if it's a new issue], and then in their Management Discussion and Analysis, about how the business is doing, where they think the opportunities are, where the risks are, and how they are going to try to manage those risks. Now, of course, people aren't perfect, so they could be wrong. And there could be some nefarious aspect, too. But by and large, people are honest, and they are trying to do the right thing.

But we're hearing about hedge funds going down. And companies can't sell commercial paper to raise money right now because investors are not willing to front the money.

The people who invest in hedge funds know they are taking a risk. They tend to be savvy.... Yes, maybe a pension fund is investing in a hedge fund, but they are not risking their last dime—they are restricted in how much they can invest in products like hedge funds. They are trying to boost their return by diversifying and taking calculated risks. As a pension fund manager, you can't just put your money in treasuries and then expect to meet your obligations 30 or 40 years down the road. So pension funds, insurance companies, and others have to try to balance their risks and expected returns.

But hedge funds aren't regulated, and there have been some sort of noticeable failures. Is it just caveat emptor?

Well, it is not entirely caveat emptor because there are a lot of rules that apply to hedge funds. Many of them voluntarily register with the SEC. No hedge fund can lie, cheat, or steal. And, to make sure everything is covered, we just promulgated a new hedge fund rule that says, basically, "Thou shalt not rip off thy limited partners."