Jeffrey Sachs on Beating Global Poverty

The Colombia economist says it can be done with little investing

April 11, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (13)

Economist Jeffrey Sachs, Columbia University's current rock star-cum-academic, has mastered the art of being audacious in a pleasantly reasoned sort of way. In his new book, Common Wealth: Economics for a Crowded Planet, he posits that global poverty, plus a host of other ills, can be conquered for a cost that amounts to pocket change for rich-world nations. The price tag, either shamefully low or totally unrealistic, prompts the question, "If we can, why haven't we?" Excerpts of a chat with Sachs:

How do you pull a country out of poverty?
The trick is to think technologically. People are poor because they lack productivity. They lack productivity because they don't have the tools to become more productive. Those tools include the basic inputs to raise farm yields above subsistence levels. For urban centers, it means broadband, electricity, and working ports. My concern is for the places that need the tools and simply can't pay for them. They're trapped. Those places are where we should give targeted help.

How much would that really cost?
For less than 1 percent of annual income of the high-income countries—the U.S., Europe, Japan, and a few others—we could end poverty once and for all. It's enough to get the poorest countries onto a path of long-term development. By ridding the world of extreme poverty, we're doing ourselves a big favor in terms of our own long-term security. Of course, it goes without saying that most of us consider helping other people a good goal in and of itself if the price is right. And in this case, the price is right.

Why not just leave it to the free market?
Free-market forces are vital. But they are limited when you have people so poor that they are essentially isolated from markets. People that don't even grow enough food to bring to market, don't have electricity or access to roads, clinics, or schools, find themselves isolated from the world economy.

With First World economies struggling, will it be tougher to gain commitments to fight poverty?
Not really, because the amounts we're talking about are so small. To control malaria comprehensively in Africa, for example, would cost less than two days of Pentagon spending.

So how should we revamp U.S. policy?
Look at the swath of instability right now that stretches across Chad, Sudan, Somalia, up through the Arabian Peninsula to Iran, Iraq, Pakistan, and Afghanistan. That whole region is enmeshed in a real crisis of massive water scarcity, food scarcity, and population stress. If we take the initiative, we'd find that for a few billion dollars there'd be an incredible rally around us, as opposed to the hundreds of billions of dollars that just aren't getting us anywhere right now.

Tags:
Columbia University

Reader Comments Read all comments (13)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

The book shows only one thing, that the author knows almost nothing about climate change. This is very sad and that is why we have a worlde wide retreat from global warming or climate change: because those guys who wanted to promote it actually don't quite understand by themselves.

Samuel ZHou of WA 10:53AM September 26, 2011

this is not good

hi of IL 9:39AM May 22, 2009

After reading Jeff's responses, I cannot help but be embarrassed by his answers. Mr. Sachs, however eloquent and polished in his answers lacks fundamental logic and understanding of Africa or the Middle East. His answers of utopian sophisticated systems that only someone of his intellect can "truly understand" are not only flawed but irresponsible and reckless.

The reality is his propagated misdirection is indirectly killing millions of people and sometimes doing good is not always good. I have visited the Millennium project in Kenya, read his book, and compared it against his boastful accomplishments, which I found to be either grossly overstated or fabricated. The project specifically in Kenya is an embarrassment to common sense, and cannot be replicated and is not a success by any stretch of the imagination. His idea that you can do 460 things to eliminate poverty only allows for more lack of accountability and excuses if the project or ideal fails. When failure occurs, Mr. Sachs blames it on corruption or internal pressures or breakdowns. When it succeeds(which it has not other than in manipulated and propagated terms) he touts his enormous intellect in understanding emerging and developing markets.

Fundamentally, the answers are simpler than the sophisticated algorithm Mr. Sachs has created. He speaks very well in his indictment of the billions we are spending to get nowhere, but does not understand the problem he is trying to dictate a solution for. I agree with his assessment of our failure, but not his solution, as it fails to again address the problem.

If Mr. Sachs for example would like to solve food scarcity issues, he must get to the root of the problem. The root is not food scarcity, but water scarcity. As you go further into the problem of water scarcity you get to the real problem which is not water scarcity but management of the resource of water. If you build reservoirs in Africa to withstand drought cycles you will be able to solve many of the underlying issues related to food scarcity. Obviously the solution is much more detailed than a one paragraph solution, but after 21,000 pages of research, interviews, assessments on the ground, and dialog with Universities and institutional professionals, I was astounded by the lack of thoughtful planning and understanding of the problem.

I have spent almost 2 years in Kenya working in partnership with a government parastatal organization to design an agricultural plantation model. I have done assessments and strategy development for Sudan both with the North and South. I understand from a high level what the issues are, and with all due respect, there is a huge disconnect between Mr. Sachs theory and reality.

Great book to read, White Man's Burden by William Easterly. Great organization which defies NGO incompetency in developing regions, Technoserve. Dont take my word for it.... Go to Kenya and see for yourself... Reality will scare you.

Joseph Oltmann of CO 5:51AM May 17, 2009

Most Connected Company

Find out how America’s best companies are succeeding by tapping big data, mobile solutions, social media, and crowdsourcing to adapt and compete in an increasingly connected world.

See the companies »

advertisement

Slide Shows

Best-Sellers to Help Your 2013 Finances

Seeking advice? Check out these acclaimed financial books.

10 Warning Signs of Identity Theft

About 10 million Americans fall victim each year.

Items You Should Buy Online

Skip the store to save money and time.

Latest Video

advertisement