One Bank Stock Worth a Look

Chicago's PrivateBancorp


Name a bank stock that's beating the S&P 500 this year. It's OK. I'll wait.

There are still a few, even after the double whammy of the Bear Stearns and the Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac debacles.

For a notable exception, check out PrivateBancorp (PVTB). The small Chicago-based regional caters mostly to wealthy Midwesterners and managed to outperform its peers even as the spread of problems in housing crimped mortgage lending, credit markets, and basic banking activities of all stripes. Shares may have fallen 6 percent year to date, but that's better than a 12 percent loss in the S&P 500 and a whopping 22 percent drop in the KBW Bank index.

The reason behind some of that (relative) strength is this: During one of the worst downturns in banking history, PrivateBancorp decided to go on a massive hiring spree.

Last year, Bank of America bought LaSalle but seemed more interested in its retail operations and less than interested in LaSalle's midsize corporate lenders.

The shakeup threw loose a small army of talent, and PrivateBancorp pounced, hiring more than 100 bankers since last November, including Larry Richman, a LaSalle veteran now installed as PrivateBancorp's new president and CEO.

"You had a mass exodus of highly skilled bankers who had strong relationships with middle-market companies," said Ben Crabtree, a Minneapolis-based analyst with Stifel Nicolaus.

The arrangement is nothing if not unique. It's essentially a team with experience managing a $75 billion bank jumping ship for a tiny institution (PrivateBancorp had $4.1 billion in loans in 2007). It's almost unheard of for such a small fish to swallow a bigger rival, especially when the entire banking sector is facing its worst year in decades.

Richman paints the jump as an opportunity to keep the long-standing LaSalle team together in a familiar locale.

"We'd worked together for between 15, 20, 25 years plus as a team. With the changes in the Chicago banking market, it created the opportunity to build an important local, commercial-relationship bank," he says. "It's an opportunity to do something special in a market that has provided us with an opportunity."

It also drastically changes the PrivateBancorp story for investors.

Basically, buying the stock is a bet that all the LaSalle folks will bring already solid business relationships along with them and push PrivateBancorp to the next level in terms of size. That is indeed happening at a rapid pace. As of 2006, the bank's total loans were $3.5 billion. As of the second quarter, they're $6.4 billion and are widely expected to head well north of $7 billion by year's end. About 75 percent of the new business came from the LaSalle bankers, the company said.

Richman doesn't put a number on year-end loan growth but says growth will be manageable because his bankers are able to court a huge base of existing clients.

"Growth in loans is coming from clients that are new to the bank but aren't new to our bankers," he said. The job—shift old business to a new company—also lets the firm be a bit pickier with the business it tries to transfer to the new bank.

Early results

So far this year, all those new bankers are earning their keep. In the second quarter, growth looked absolutely stunning. Loan growth exploded by 25 percent compared with the first quarter (not the year-ago quarter, where that sort of number would still look pretty good given tough times in the sector). Most loans were commercial and industrial, rather than for riskier commercial real estate or construction hit by the housing and credit crisis (the mix was $882 million, $217 million, and $83 million).

Shares jumped as much as 17 percent on July 29 when earnings were announced, despite the fact that paying for all the new talent continues to result in bigger losses. Quarterly results show that the bank's large-scale poaching comes at an uncertain price. Salary and benefit expenses in the quarter jumped to $31.8 million from $12.7 million. Basically, analysts are waiting to see if the new team can turn in good results. The bank had told investors its plan would mean some near-term pain (Richman calls 2008 an "investment year"), but analysts trimmed their estimates after a loss of 40 cents a share in the quarter missed Wall Street's expectation of a 24-cent loss.

  • Kirk Shinkle

    Kirk Shinkle is a senior editor for U.S. News Money and manages the Best Funds portal. Follow him on Twitter @KirkS or email him at