Overrated Career: Professor

December 11, 2008 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (42)

The Appeal: After four years, you've got your Ph.D. and get to live a life of the mind on a halcyon campus. You help students to flower and conduct research that will make a difference, while enjoying maximum job security, thanks to lifetime tenure after just seven years. And with the cushy 30-week school year, you have lots of time off.

The Reality: The average total time to a Ph.D. is 10 years. And even a Ph.D. from a prestigious university far from guarantees a tenure-track professorship.

Even if you beat the odds, the professor's life is no picnic:

To get tenure, which takes seven years, one typically must, in addition to a carrying full teaching load and advising students, publish original research, serve on committees, and perform other university service. That means long hours and not even close to getting the summers off.

Even if they get tenure, many professors experience considerable frustration:

  • the large gap between their intellects and drive and those of their students
  • the desire to teach well but a lack of training on how to do so, and a tenure and promotion system that so heavily weighs research that it's self-destructive to focus too much effort on teaching
  • the inordinate office politics (it's been said that nowhere else does so much intellect go into fighting over so little)
  • the lack of ideological diversity. On many campuses, political correctness is rampant.

The Alternatives: university librarian, program analyst.

Tags:
teachers,
careers,
education

Reader Comments Read all comments (42)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Who thinks a Doctorate takes four years?

Jennifer of WA 12:47AM June 04, 2013

There are pros and cons in each profession. If it is for you then the pros will outwiegh the cons in your eyes.

Lauren of FL 5:42PM July 06, 2012

This post stereotypes way too much. Yes, there are situations in academia in which students are lazy idiots and professors are frustrated geniuses.

There are also situations in which students benefit from and learn alongside a professor who starts an interesting conversation that is relevant to students’ lives. I see no reason to disrespect the intellect of “their students” without dealing with specific cases of behavior in the classroom, and without keeping in mind that a good professor will inspire students to learn in the same way that a bad professor will turn students off and not enhance their students’ intellect.

I think that if people want more intellectual diversity on college campuses, then all that they have to do is speak their mind freely. This is a free country, and I don’t see how specific cases of campus politics are good reasons for not entering into any field. Politics is everywhere… let’s not pretend that the same kind of fighting can’t be found in libraries, banks, etc.

And finally, on a more general note, we need more responsible and positive people to enter academia at a time when our society is in need of help. Let’s talk about how to make academia less political more suitable for society’s needs, but let’s stop discouraging people from entering positions that can make a positive difference in the lives of others.

JP of NY 2:30PM April 07, 2012

Jobs 2020

Who will have a thriving career, and who won't? Find out what will drive America's workforce.

Jobs in 2020 »

Jobs That May Interest You

See Jobs Near You

advertisement

Slide Shows

20 Work-Life Balance Hacks

Tips that will help you get more work done and have more time to play.

Quiz: The Hottest Healthcare Jobs This Decade

Take this quiz to learn more about the best jobs for healthcare workers.

14 Must-Have Items for Any Business Trip

Make sure to pack these essentials for your next trip.

Latest Video

advertisement