The 5 Best—and 5 Worst—Home Improvement Projects for Your Money

January 27, 2010 RSS Feed Print
  • Comment (18)

But Kuperszmid Lehrman argues that a homeowner's true return on this particular investment depends on how many bathrooms they already have. Homes with one less bathroom than comparable properties in the neighborhood would be better served by this project. "If you are a bathroom short, depending on what's going on in your neighborhood, then it is going to make more sense," she says.

4. Backup power generator: Homeowners who obtain a backup power generator recoup on average only about 59 percent of the project's cost when they sell the home, according to the report. Although most homeowners don't consider a backup power generator essential, its popularity varies a great deal from one region to another. Those living in communities where tornados, hurricanes, or blizzards could knock out power for days are more likely to be drawn to homes with this feature, Alfano says. "Being out of power in Florida might not be that big of a deal in February, whereas in Vermont [a backup power generator] makes a huge difference," Alfano says.

5. Garage addition: Homeowners who build a garage addition recoup on average about 62 percent of the project's cost when they sell the home, according to the report. Lipford argues that the limited versatility of a garage doesn't necessarily justify its high cost, which can average more than $58,000. A garage addition project is a labor intensive effort, often requiring builders to pour a slab, construct walls, and build a roof, among other things. "The only thing that is keeping it from being legitimate living space is insulated walls for air conditioning and heating—so it does represent a high cost to do that for strictly sheltering cars [or storing belongings]," Lipford said. "So when you start going down the check list of things you have to do, [the garage addition] starts moving down the list."

Tags:
home improvements

Reader Comments Read all comments (18)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

Vinyl siding, vinyl windows and steel entry doors? Where is it that these "improvements" would be expected to increase the value of a house? A trailer park? Or maybe a slum. These features look bad when they are new and just get tackier as they age. Vinyl accumulates slimy mold-like growth as it starts to warp and sag. Steel rusts and won't hold paint after a while. Wood siding can be stained if painting is too much of a hassle and unlike vinyl siding it can be patched to keep it going indefinitely. The best advice here is to avoid replacing windows unless they are beat up or broken. Old windows can be re-furbished for less than the cost of a plastic replacement, if you are working with someone who knows (and cares) how. And, no matter what the cold-calling charlatans tell you, a double-pane window won't be significantly more efficient than a well-maintained wood window with a separate storm layer, but it probably won't last as long.

PCL of MA 9:08PM January 25, 2013

Interesting article. The one thing that homeowners overlook...if they manage their own remodeling projects they will more times than not come out ahead. Meaning, the value of the project will exceed the costs. This extra value comes from taking on the general contractor role and by doing some work yourself. To find out more about this check out http://armchairbuilder.com/

Michael of OH 4:21PM October 09, 2012

I have been looking to build a good professionnal opinion on the topic. Your post got me a step further in the right direction. Many thanks :-)

http://www.executivetouchrenovations.com/

FrankMalvyn of CA 4:36AM July 20, 2012

advertisement

rounded corners

Slideshows »
10 ‘Digital Utilities’ You Need Every Day

Latest Video

advertisement