• Comment (6)

Should Seniors Live Alone or With Family?

Weak economy, and now longevity and savings challenges, accelerating growth of multigenerational households

March 20, 2012 RSS Feed Print

The longevity conundrum. Healthcare presents a mixed picture for boomers; active lifestyles and treatment developments are helping stave off some disease, but longer living also raises the odds of multiple serious conditions in advanced years and the need for body maintenance, such as joint replacement.

Some households are able to accommodate parents with physical issues and the care industry is responding with more flexibility, often traveling to see patients. But eventually, no matter how welcoming younger generations are to opening their homes to the seniors, they may just not be able to handle the level of care needed.

The home versus care-facility debate welcomes a whole new round of cost concerns. According to Genworth Financial's 2011 Cost of Care Survey, while the cost to receive care in an assisted living facility or nursing home increased over the past year, the cost to receive care in the home, Americans' preferred long-term care setting, remained unchanged. Nationally, the median annual cost of long-term care in an assisted living facility is $39,135, an increase of 2.4 percent from 2010. The comparable cost for a private nursing home room rose 3.4 percent, to $77,745. At $18 per hour for homemaker services and $19 an hour for home-health aide services, the median hourly cost to receive care in the home remained flat over the past 12 months.

[See Should You Buy Long-Term Care Insurance?]

Aging consultancy Age Wave says some older Americans cling too much to the notion of independence in their own home and don't fully weigh the costs and benefits of retirement facilities.

Based on a study, the group offers a list of five myth-busters that may help families make these tough decisions:

• My current home will be the best place to live in retirement. Many retirees believe remaining in their house gives them the most freedom and independence. But the reality is that by staying at home, they spend twice as much time doing housework and shopping as someone in a retirement center.

• My current home is the best option to lead an active life and stay connected. Among those over 80, nearly half report suffering from loneliness—twice the rate of younger adults. Depression, alcohol abuse, and obesity can follow.

• Home is less expensive. Among homeowners older than 65, 84 percent have paid off the mortgage. Still, a house is expensive. Taxes, utilities, upkeep, and insurance really add up.

• It would be easy to get any care I might need at home. This may be true. But home-health care can further isolate anyone unable to get out. It is also expensive and can add to burdens on extended family.

• Retirement centers are filled with people who are sick and dying. This may be the most off-putting myth. Today's centers are not where old people go to die. This is partly because most centers require new residents to be in good health and be able to live independently when entering the community.

Let's talk. Families are challenged to communicate their needs and desires for a housing solution. Cultural differences certainly determine the "acceptance" of multiple generations in a single household, but for the most part, the concept has moved in and out of trend in the United States. Needless to say, it's a touchy subject.

In a Metlife Mature Market Institute online survey of 2,123 Americans ages 21 to 65, conducted from June 29 to July 20, 2011, nearly half—46 percent across generations—believe children have a responsibility to provide financial support to their own parents or in-laws if they experience financial difficulty later in life. For many, this means allowing a parent to live with them if he or she is not healthy enough to live alone without caregiving (58 percent overall call this a strong or absolute responsibility), or allowing a parent to live with them if he or she is having financial trouble (50 percent). At the same time, however, many parents say they would not accept financial assistance from their children in old age.

Tags:
family,
home improvements,
money

Reader Comments Read all comments (6)

Add Your Thoughts
Your comment will be posted immediately, unless it is spam or contains profanity. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

My family is facing this issue with my mother now. At this point she needs more than the family can emotionally provide. She is no longer the same person she was even six months ago. She is 91 and has always lived in the house my father built for her and her children were raised in. Ours is not a close family. When my husband was alive we assumed looking out for her, making sure she got to medical appointments, groceries, prescriptions etc. as well as some financial assistance and providing contact to prevent isolation. Now my brother who lives out of state is doing most of it as I am disabled and she doesn't answer her phone most of the time which limits our contact. I go to doctor's appointments with her and spend time with her when my brother is home. My other two brothers want no responsibility for the decisions to be made. Her mind is very fragile, she won't eat or take her meds and refuses outside help. She is falling a lot and is short of breath. It is going to be a difficult decision to make but I don't have room to have her live with me and I don't think I could physically do it and I don't think it would be workable for her to live with my brother. She would have to sell her home to move into assisted living if she could handle living in a situation like that. I think she needs more care but I hate to see her in a nursing home. My husband died in one and he was only 54. It wasn't anyplace you would want to see anybody live out their days.

Sally R Goodrich of VT 9:08PM December 30, 2012

While aging-in-place may be a good option for some people, it may not be a good solution for others. Even though seniors can receive assistance with personal care and chores while still remaining home, the one issue that is hard to solve is isolation and loneliness if there are no friends or family members visiting regularly. Therefore, for some, independent living and assisted living are better solutions since they provide more socialization with a variety of activities. For more information about available options, please visit www.goldenyearslivingsolutions.com.

Carol Smrek of NY 8:07AM April 09, 2012

Quality Advantage Home Products, Inc., is one of the nations leaders installing acrylic and premium granite bath systems. Serving greater Hampton Roads since 1997, Quality Advantage takes pride in all facets of bathroom remodeling. From tub to shower conversions and Safety Tubs for seniors and the disabled to creating beautiful new looks in as little as just one day, Quality Advantage is your local choice for the highest quality and reliable service. Call us today for a free no cost consultation at 1-877-500-1884. For more information visit us at http://www.qahomeproducts.com

Quality Advantage of VA 2:54PM April 03, 2012

advertisement

Latest Video

advertisement

How to Live to 100

Why do some people live long, healthy, and happy lives, while others struggle with dementia, heart disease, and depression? Learn how to protect yourself from those outcomes based on the latest research on health, longevity, happiness, and finances in the U.S. News ebook.